Why do I keep hearing Parfums de Marly described as basic? I am asking the question because I genuinely enjoy Layton. My wife likes it too, and I have received compliments while wearing it.

I tried Carlisle and Dorval side by side on skin. Carlisle felt richer and darker and projected strongly on me. Dorval was a little brighter and spicy, developing into a smooth, warm, woodsy character. I preferred Dorval overall, even though Carlisle had the stronger presence.

My nose is still developing. I am not claiming that fragrance enthusiasts all agree, or that an approachable fragrance is automatically less interesting. I am looking for something with the appeal I find in Layton and Dorval, perhaps with a character that feels a little more my own.