Tom Ford was promoting Tobacco Chocolat during our mall visit, and my wife really liked it. Despite the name, I was not getting much chocolate. To me it felt more like rich, sweet honey with some tobacco emerging underneath.

Friends at the mall suggested Guerlain Tobacco Honey, so I put both on skin and compared them through the rest of the day. Guerlain gave me a similarly rich honey impression, with more tobacco, depth and a development I found more dynamic.

On my skin that day, Guerlain’s staying power was noticeably better. We liked both fragrances, but I kept returning to Tobacco Honey. That is the result of our particular comparison, not an objective longevity ranking or a verdict on either whole house.

If you have worn them side by side, did either change your mind as the day went on?