Dorval was the surprise in my side-by-side comparison with Carlisle. It felt brighter and a little spicy at the opening, then became smooth, warm and woody as it settled. I kept coming back to its character rather than how loudly it announced itself.
Carlisle was richer, darker and stronger-projecting on my skin. I preferred Dorval overall. It gave me that beautifully finished, almost high-quality-aftershave feeling I enjoy, even though Carlisle made the bigger impression across the room.

