Carlisle was the darker, richer side of my comparison with Dorval. It had more presence on my skin and a noticeably stronger projection, with the kind of sweet, spicy and woody weight that makes a fragrance feel substantial.

I can appreciate that character without choosing it over everything else. Dorval was the one I preferred wearing in this comparison. Carlisle is worth smelling alongside it because the difference makes the choice much clearer than either fragrance’s popularity does.