By the Fireplace takes vanilla somewhere quite different. When I tried it at the mall, the opening felt sharp, burnt and woody, with clove and a roasted-chestnut character. It was the smoke that made the first impression.

As it settled, the chestnut became warmer and sweeter, and vanilla appeared underneath with the wood smoke still lingering. That progression was the interesting part for me. It showed how far a vanilla fragrance can move from something simply creamy or edible.