We travel with them in tandem rather than treating one as the winner. July is my case, while my wife has built up an Away collection. The shared advantage is the top-opening layout. Choose the dimensions, weight and bag system that suit your trips, then check the airlines' cabin limits.
July
Capsule Carry On Pro
Bought it
We use July's top-opening case while my wife uses her Away. Both work well; shoes and awkward items are easier to pack without two shallow halves.

The trade-off
Check the case dimensions and weight against the airlines you fly.
