Top access makes packing easier without dividing everything between two shallow shells. Our choice between these cases isn't a verdict that one brand beats the other: my wife already enjoys the Away system, while I use July. Compare the actual dimensions of the Topside and Bigger Carry-On before ordering.
Away
Topside Carry-On
Bought it
My wife uses the Away as part of her wider collection of Away bags. We travel with it alongside the July, and both have worked well for us.

The trade-off
The Topside Carry-On and Bigger Carry-On are different sizes.
